
A totally pointless, completely worthless, and absolutely ridiculous exercise examining professional baseball, position-by-position, in Pittsburgh: The dark years, where disappointment and unintentional hilarity have reigned supreme.
Catcher - Benito Santiago. Only played six games with the Pirates, registering 23 at-bats during the 2005 season. The first replacement for Jason Kendall, hit .261 and was 40 years old on opening day, looked to be 400 years old. Later linked to steroids. Followed at the position by Ronny Paulino for two uninspiring, lazy years. Later linked to Pizza Hut's all you can eat $5.99 lunch buffet. Three times a day. Every day.
First Base - Ron Wright. Acquired in the Denny Neagle trade during the 1996 season, considered to be the prize of the deal as a power-hitting, shit-stomping, ass-kicking franchise first baseman with "light tower power" that was going to be one of the core building blocks to then General Manager Cam Bonifay's five-year plan that would eventually return the Pirates to dominance and glory. Suffered a series of injuries in the Minor Leagues and never played a game with the Pirates. Bounced around the minors for a few years before finally getting called up for the Seattle Mariners in 2002. He had three at-bats on April 14 in a game against the Texas Rangers.
In his first big league at-bat in the top of the second inning, Wright struck out looking.
In his second big league at-bat in the top of the fourth inning, Wright hit into a triple play.
In his third, and final, big league at-bat in the top of the sixth inning, Wright hit into a double play.
In his one game, in three at-bats, he accounted for six of his teams 27 outs. It's a wonder how he didn't do it for the Pirates. He never played again in the Major Leagues.
Honorable mention: Randall Simon. Infamously smacked a Milwaukee Sausage with his bat as it raced by him while he was sitting on the bench. Was re-signed by the Pirates after failing miserably his first time with the team.
Second Base - Carlos Garcia. Perhaps the worst All-Star ever, in what was perhaps one of the greatest All-Star game ever. It's not really surprising that
this was one of the best baseball games the city of Pittsburgh has seen during the dark years. Garcia ended his All-Star season with a .267 average, .309 On-Base Percentage and a .367 Slugging Percentage. Statistically, he was the worst every day player on the 1994 Pirates. Later traded in a monster, mega deal (along with Orlando Merced and Dan Plesac) to the Toronto Blue Jays for six minor leaguers who, along with Ron Wright, were going to help turn the Pirates into contenders by 2002.

Shortstop - Pat Meares. Signed as a free agent by the Pirates before the 1999 season after playing six seasons with the Minnesota Twins. Never had an OPS+ over 100 (100 being an average hitter in a given season) in any season. Originally was signed to a one-year deal, but when he arrived at spring training he hit the ball all over the field, with power, and impressed General Manager Cam Bonifay so much, that Bonifay was willing to ignore six years of mediocrity and sign Meares to a 4-year, $12 million contract. Meares ended up suffering a major injury to his hand and suddenly became even worse at the plate and in the field. Allegedly a prominent member of the Giles/Kendall/Williams clique and rumors began to surface that when Meares was essentially banished from the team, a Pat Meares shrine was (allegedly) erected in the clubhouse to send some sort of message to management. Unless that message was, "We demand more mediocre, overpaid, douche bags" it was pretty pointless. Assuming it happened.

Third Base - Joe Randa. Perhaps the finest example of the dark years, and a testament to everything that has gone wrong over the past 15 seasons.
Nothing against Joe Randa, he always seemed like a nice enough guy, always had a smile on his face, and seemed to just really enjoy being a big league baseball player. And for a brief period of time, he wasn't half bad. So, what's the problem? Well...
After the 1996 season the Pirates acquired Randa, along with pitchers Jeff Granger and Jeff Wallace (guys who were also going to return the Pirates to championship contenders in 2002) for Jeff King and Jay Bell, the teams two best players. Randa was a 26-year old third baseman while Wallace and Granger were young, flame throwing horses that were going to anchor the Pirates pitching staff for decades to come. The two pitchers fizzled out, while Randa started at third base for the 1997 "Freak Show" team that almost miraculously won the National League Central (which even then was a laughing stock). Randa was a fan favorite that season, hitting over .300 with a fine On-Base Percentage and nine triples. He was never going to be the future of the position, he was simply a place-holder until hot-shot prospect Aramis Ramirez could take over the position.
For reasons that defy all logic, Cam Bonifay left Randa unprotected in the following off-seasons expansion draft and helplessly watched as Randa was selected by the Arizona Diamondbacks, leaving the Pirates with a black hole at the third base position. This then resulted in Ramirez being rushed to the Majors during the 1998 season, and struggling terribly for parts of three seasons. He looked as if he were going to be a terrible, epic bust, and was then traded to the Chicago Cubs for spare parts, again leaving the Pirates with another glaring hole at third base. As this hole still remained years later, the Pirates signed a 36-year old -- and completely washed up -- Joe Randa prior to the 2006 season to man the third base position, thus relegating Freddy Sanchez to bench duty. Randa hit .267 in 260 at-bats. Freddy Sanchez won the National League batting title.
Joe Randa...full circle with the Pirates.

The outfield...so many choices, so few spots:
Left Field - Derek Bell. Signed by the Pirates prior to the 2001 season to a mind blowing contract that was going to pay him $5 million per season, for two years. The deal was insane because (1) Derek Bell wasn't that good (2) Derek Bell was washed up (3) the Pirates had a far more productive player already on the roster in John Vander Wal. Manager Lloyd McClendon made his infamous, "This move sent shockwaves through baseball" quote, and handed Bell the outfield spot that should have gone to Vander Wal, the superior player. Bell, predictably, was terrible, and the following off-season was informed that he would not be handed a starting job and would have to earn his spot in spring training. Bell was not amused and informed the Pirates, media and fans that if he had to complete for anything that he would go into "operation shutdown." Following the tirade, he skipped out of camp on his house boat and a legend of futility was born. The joke at the time was that Bell was a real life Pirate, considering he lived on a boat and was stealing money for a living. Hit .173 with a .287 On-Base Percentage and .288 Slugging Percentage in 156 at-bats with the Pirates.

Center Field - Chad Hermansen. Originally drafted as a short stop in the first round of the 1996 draft, Hermansen became a power-hitting Center Fielder that was the very definition of a five-tool player (I think). One scout at the time said of Hermansen, "He could walk on water if he wanted to." Apparently, he didn't want to. Hermansen was one of the Pirates most disappointing prospect failures in a decade full of disappointing prospects. Hit .195 in 492 big league at-bats. Traded by the Pirates at the 2002 trade deadline for Darren Lewis. Lewis retired the next day.
Right Field - Raul Mondesi. I remember the night the Pirates signed Raul Mondesi. Fox Sports Pittsburgh announcer Greg Brown was on a local call-in show gushing about the possibility of Mondesi signing with the Pirates, talking about how his right-handed power and rifle arm would be just what the Pirates needed. I mean, it's Raul Freakin' Mondesi.
Mondesi was always seen as a malcontent and it seemed that every team he played for couldn't get rid of him fast enough. Critics of the signing wondered just what would happen when you combined the highly combustible Mondesi with a team that was destined to lose, and lose a lot. The critics, as it turned out, were spot on with their concerns.
After playing 26 forgettable games with the Pirates, Mondesi -- clearly bored with all of the losing -- left the team for what he claimed were personal reasons (something about threats from a past instructor) and his contract was essentially thrown away. Ten days later he signed with Anaheim.
Became inspiration for the fantastic Pittsburgh sports site, Mondesi's House.
Honorable mentions - Al Martin. Once lied about playing football at USC, married to multiple women at the same time without any of them knowing.
Brant Brown. Outfielder who used a frying pan for a glove, acquired by Cam Bonifay for starting pitcher Jon Lieber. Not only did Bonifay trade a very good starting pitcher for the stone-handed Brown, he did so under the assumption that Brant Brown could play center field. He could not.
Starting Pitcher -Matt Morris. Currently the highest paid player on the Pirates, by a wide margin, and one of the most worthless. Acquired just minutes before the trade deadline during the 2007 season in a move that can only be described as bat shit bonkers. It's not that the Pirates gave up anything of any relevance (because they didn't) it's just that Matt Morris is finished, making a ton of money, and woefully awful. One baseball insider -- whose name I'm forgetting at the moment, I'm sorry -- said, "That deal is so out of left field it's in the Monongahela." Not only did the Pirates acquire Morris, but they took on his entire contract which had $12 million dollars remaining for just over one season of awful, awful baseball. We consider it Dave Littlefields going away present. He has no current trade value to the Pirates, unless of course, Dave Littlefield becomes General Manager of another Major League Baseball team in the very near future.
Relief Pitcher - Mike Williams. Erratic closer that racked up some impressive save numbers, despite loading the bases with no out in just about every appearance. Somehow pitched in two All-Star games as a member of the Pirates, including one season where he went into the mid-summer classic with an ERA over 5.00. Part of the infamous Brian Giles/Pat Meares clique that stole lunch money from Jack Wilson and showered naked together.

Honorable mentions - Josias Manzanillo. Maniac pitcher who pitched in two different stints with the Pirates. Would scream at himself on the mound while smacking his head before every pitch, and would then jump off the mound and sprint to the dugout when the final out of the inning was recorded, regardless of the score or situation. Age: Unknown. Estimated to be between 400 and 600. Brian Boehringer. Another psycho, kept books about serial killers in his locker and once screamed at Jack Wilson for failing to come up with a ground ball. Almost fought him in the dugout, had to be restrained by teammates. Drew the fancy of Brian Giles who once joked that he enjoyed watching Boehringer lather himself up in the shower.Bench Coach - Jim Tracy. Out of touch manager for two pointless seasons, had a habit of answering questions from reporters during interviews and press conferences with questions of his own, that he would then ponder and answer. Example:
Reporter: Jim, what happened to Zach Duke in the fourth inning tonight?
Jim Tracy: What happened to Zach Duke tonight? Well, what happens with Zach Duke every night? Zach Duke just couldn't keep the ball down and in the zone. Does he have the ability to do that on a consistent basis? Sure. Will he do it every fifth day? I don't know. That's a good question.
According to
Post-Gazette beat writer Dejean Kovacevic, Tracy had a bizarre fascination with taking his Pirates team and attempting to turn them into a recreated version of his 2003 Dodgers team. He took Jack Wilson and told him to field like Cesar Izturis (whom the Pirates later traded for, likely at Tracy's request) and told Jason Bay to decline like he was Shawn Green. Okay, I made that part up. But he did try to get Wilson to field grounders like Cesar Izturis.

Manager -Lloyd McClendon. Was convinced signing Derek Bell and Terry Mulholland in the same off-season was not only a good idea, but that Major League Baseball as a whole would be shocked by it. They were shocked all right, but for reasons that differed from McClendon's. Once proved that it was possible to steal first base. Had a series of opening day gaffes which included using Ron Villone as his opening day starting pitcher, to hitting Tike Redman third. Liked to refer to players as "bulldogs."
General Manager - Dave Littlefield.Don't tell him, but that phone's not even plugged in.
Owner - Bob Nutting.