After starting off 1-3 and then having a weekend like last week where everything fell perfectally into place for us I thought the Steelers were sitting pretty...and then today happened, and in this heat of the moment so soon after the contest i'm not even really sure what exactly happened. I'm actually starting to think my view of football is really twisted from reality, my dad and brother are going to great lengths to try and convince me that todays game is not in the hands of the defense. Okay...fine. You can argue that Santonio Holmes fumble was costly (and you're damn right)...you can argue that Willie Parker and Ben Roethlisbergers fumbles were costly (and you're damn right) and you can even argue that the special teams played bad in general (and you're damn right again)...but here is my argument:
There is no rule that says you have to give up a touchdown right after a turnover. Or in some cases, one play after a turnover. As crazy as it is to believe, there is this novel idea of holding teams to field goals after turnovers, or even more novel...creating a turnover of your own to get the ball back.
After Santonio Holmes fumbled punt return early in the first quarter the Atlanta Falcons took exactly one play to score a touchdown. A 23 yard pass to Alge Crumpler.
After the Ben Roethlisberger fumble, the Steelers had Atlanta in a 3rd and 7 situation (a stop would have held them to a field goal attempt) and they allowed a 12 yard first down to Alge Crumler (again) and THEN had a roughing the passer penalty tacked on...result: First and goal..touchdown 2 plays later...on third down...to Alge Crumpler.
I'm starting to notice a trend.
I love the Steelers defense as much as anyone, and i'm not convinced that they are a long term problem, but today, they wet the proverbial bed and were the biggest factor in the Steelers loss. Giving up 41 points to a Michael Vick led offense is not acceptable in any league at any time, I don't care how many turnovers you had or how many onside kicks they recovered. Atlanta entered todays game as the worst Red Zone offense in the NFL...they were 31% on third downs...and Michael Vick had a Michael Vick like passer rating of 60 something.
Today? They were pretty close to perfect in the redzone, 50% on third downs, and Vick threw 4 touchdown passes...he had never thrown more than 2 in any game in his career.
- All that being said, there were two things about todays game that frustrated me more than the game itself. Which speaks volumes as to how frustrating these next two items were.......
1. Jim Nantz and Phil Simms.
2. The people I watched the game with.
Lets start with the latter. Normally I have two different groups I watch the games with when i'm not actually at the game...A group of my friends, and a group that consists of my parents, one of my brothers and a group of their friends. Today I was with the Parent group. I love watching games with my dad...we argue at times about the plays, sometimes heated, sometimes we get mad at each other, but we still have a blast, my problem was not with him...it was with, well.... everybody else.
To set the scene for you, we are in a basement of this house...a nice house, a quality basement, and about 20-25 people crammed in. It makes for a cozy atmosphere and what not, but every week it's the same thing...
Nobody watches the game (minus my dad and myself...we usually sit off in a corner by ourselves and scream at each other about why we're losing)....
Everyone is more concerned about who's winning the gambling games they have going on and trying to talk to me about work and some other garbage that has nothing to do with anything. I'm not there to chit chat with you about my job or to have small talk about who is moving in to the house across the street from me...i'm there to drink beer, eat food and watch football...not quite in that order, but for those reasons. Any order will do really.
I'm going somewhere else next week.
As for Jim Nantz and Phil Simms...they just suck.
- As brutal as todays loss was (much like the other 3 losses this season what we seemingly gave away for the taking) i'm still not throwing in the towel. There is still a lot of football left to be played and the Steelers defense is not going to play this bad every week, they may never play this bad again. The key is going to be keeping Ben Roethlisberger in one piece, if we can do that for a couple weeks at a time he appears to be back and better than...well...ever.
After putting up a near perfect game last week he was rolling along today with a 147.3 rating before getting knocked out (literally)...I thought that play could have been flagged, but there is no use in complaining about it...that stuff happens. Move on. It just sucks that he got hurt. No real word on the extent of his injury yet (atleast not that i've heard), but you can assume it's atleast a concussion....which would not exactly be a good thing. You would think somebody on the network coverage would have a report on such a significant injury to such a significant player but who has time for that when Mike Vick is playing? Usually when a guy gets injured the networks disguise a reporter as a team doctor and send them behind enemy lines to figure out what happened...but not today.
The Vick hype gets under my skin because to this point in his career he's been no more successful than Kordell Stewart was in his Steeler days, and everyone hated Kordell Stewart...in Pittsburgh and outside of Pittsburgh. Is he a talented player? One of the most talented i've ever seen. Can he be dazzling at times? Sure. Does that make him a great player? No. He's Kordell Stewart...which isn't exactly bad (really, it's not) but lets not make him out to be the 2nd coming of John Elway. At one point today Phil Simms actually made the comment "I see a lot of John Elway in Michael Vick right here."
John Elway by the way, is arguably one of the best football players in the history of football players, the only real comparison between Michael Vick and John Elway is the fact they have the same number on the back of their uniforms...all comparisons between the two start and end there.
On this particular play Vick ran around in the backfield a little bit (with little to no pressure on him) and threw a pass down the seam to a wide open Alge Crumpler, Simms was in awe of the pass and was going on about how "Not all Quarterbacks can make this play." I don't know, it seems to me that just about every QB in the NFL should be able to make such a throw, but I haven't spent the past 15 years watching Chris Simms overthrow wide open recievers down the seam so what do I know?
- Sadly, the Steelers had a 10 point lead today and lost the game. This goes back to my midweek posting where I commented on Bill Cowhers record with 10 point leads at any point in the game...i'm not sure what it means but two of the maybe 4 or 5 games that the Steelers have not won when they had a 10 point lead in the Bill Cowher era came at the hands of the legendary Mike Vick and the Atlanta Falcons (Todays meltdown and the 2002 sister kisser). Not sure what that means, except that Michael Vick has Bill Cowhers number.
- Stupid rule comments of the week:
Either you can have celebrations...or you can't have any. In two different games today i've seen two completely absurd unsportsmanlike conduct penalty calls after touchdowns. The one in the Steelers game and one on Antwan Randle-El in the Redskins game. Randle-El did nothing more than run into the goal post in a Steve Smith like manner...El got flagged. And after another penalty on the kickoff (on the kicker for removing his helmet for no more than a half a second, honestly, if you blinked you missed him remove his helmet) the Redskins found themselves kicking off from their own 5 yard line.
The Steelers penalty still has me confused...who was it on? What was it for? For three guys doing some weak jig in the endzone? For Hines Ward nudging a Falcons player who got in the way of the jig? Personally, I hate celebrations that take any ounce of planning and practice, it's one of those few things where I consider myself "old school"...you scored, great, do like Heath Miller, toss the ball to the official and go to the sidelines...
On the other hand, football is an emotional game...you made a big play and you're damn excited about it. So maybe a little celebration is okay... There just seems to be to much gray area here...why is it okay for ONE guy to do a weak jig and not get a flag...but if somebody else on his team joins in, it's not okay.
Lookin' at my sandles. Thats a paddlin'.
Lookin' out the window. Thats a paddlin'.
More than one guy celebrating in the endzone. Thats a paddlin'.
Paddlin' the School canoe...Ohhhh, you better believe thats a paddlin'.
If you want to cut down on the celebrations eliminate them all together and flag everyone.
Or...if you're going to deem some okay, allow all of them.
- Bill Simmons once wrote in a column that after your team wins a championship you should give them a five year grace period before complaining about them again. I've been thinking about that comment this season because, well, because we won a championship last year (WEEEEEE!) and are playing like...well...not like champions so far this season.
1. I spend a lot of money and devote a ton time to the Steelers (probably more than I should on both accounts)...tickets, merchandise, jerseys, hats...when they play bad, i'm upset. As I should be. As I have a right to be.
2. When you give somebody a 5 year grace period after a championship you do nothing but allow yourself to settle into an acceptable level of Baltimore Ravens like mediocrity...Thats not a good thing and that is not what I want to become.
When the game itself is actually going on, I find myself irrational and filled with knee jerk reactions...thats the heat of the moment, i'm used to it. Once the game ends however, and I take a step back common sense begins to rear it's head. Should I be frustrated right now? Yeah. But the last 8 weeks of last season were so much fun and brought me so much joy that I should be able to put up with a slow start the following season. Be reasonable Adam, be reasonable. It's not always going to be like last season, sometimes I lose that perspective.
- Oh My God the Raiders have won. I was rooting for them to pull off the 0-16 run but in a way i'm kind of glad that they managed to win one before we play them next week. I was actually kind of worried about going in there against a desperate team that was still searching for a win...to many bad things could have happened.
Dennis Greens seat meanwhile is white hot. Should be a great press conference tonight.